
42
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 06 - n 05 - ano 2026
Emmanuel et al.
(2020)
England; cross-sectional;
2,959 respondents analyzed,
in 48 hospitals.
Shifts ≥12 h were associated with
lower educational opportunities:
OR 0.58; 95%CI 0.44–0.76.
Self-report and data from
2009–2010; association
without causation.
Maluwa, Mwalabu
and Msiska (2021)
Malawi; qualitative; 73
participants from four
hospitals.
Ethics education and supervision
were described as supporting
ethical competence.
Perceptions and intentional
selection; does not assess
change after intervention.
Melariri, Kalinda
and Chimbari
(2021)
South Africa; cross-
sectional; 495 professionals
in the total sample;
analyzable hospital strata.
The tertiary stratum presented
gaps in the provision of training for
health promotion.
Separate hospital outcomes;
self-report and variable
denominators were used.
Rahmah, Hariyati
and Sahar (2021)
Indonesia; qualitative; six
nurses.
Professional development,
accreditation and management
support were related to the
maintenance of competencies.
Small and non-probabilistic
sample; no effect on
patients.
Yu, Huang and Liu
(2022)
China; qualitative; 14
tertiary hospital nurses.
Needs vary with professional
trajectory; work and family make
participation diffi cult.
Single center and
perceptions; limited
contextual transference.
Gomes and Ribeiro
(2023)
Brazil; qualitative; 35
professionals from two adult
ICUs.
Recognition of the relevance of PEH
coexisted with specifi c educational
practices and diffi culties in
participation.
44 refusals among 79
guests; daytime sample
only.
Wehabe,
Gebretensaye and
Bizuwork (2024)
Ethiopia; mixed method;
262 responses and nine
informants.
90 of 262 nurses reported
participation in CPD; time,
funding, and information barriers.
Temporal defi nition of
participation is not uniform;
self-report.
Munyaneza et al.
(2024)
Rwanda; qualitative; 35
hospital professionals, with
nurses.
Availability did not guarantee
access; relevance of the themes,
mentoring and participation in
planning were demands.
Multiprofessional results;
not attributable only to
nursing.
Mukamana et al.
(2024)
Rwanda; transversal; 140
professionals, including 88
nurses.
Digital platforms were used, but
internet connectivity and cost
made access diffi cult.
Convenience; low
consistency in two
subscales; no measured
clinical effect.
Gaus, Conway and
Herrera (2024)
Ecuador; descriptive
evaluation of the program;
two hospitals; 108
participants in the nursing
category.
Modules on the Chamilo platform
had full participation and approval
after up to two attempts.
Obligation linked to salary;
without transfer control or
evaluation.
Hamukoto et al.
(2025)
Namibia; qualitative; 15
nurses from a reference
hospital.
Lack of staff, time, digital
resources, funding and trainers
restricted participation.
Single hospital; perceptions
without statistical
generalization.
Karikari et al.
(2025)
Ghana; transversal; 406
nurses from 11 district
hospitals.
Refresher training was associated
with an additional 3.3 percentage
points in the knowledge test.
Intentional sampling in
the day shift; association
without causal inference.