185
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
VIOLENCE AGAINST CHILDREN AND ADOLESCENTS: ANALYSIS OF
THE TRAINING OF FUTURE GENERALIST DOCTORS IN THE FACE OF
SUSPECTED CASES IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF RIO DE JANEIRO - RJ
Lays Costa Silva1
Elizabeth Alt Parente2
Ana Beatriz Azevedo Barbosa Mambreu3
Cristiana Correa Ferreira4
Daniela Bonatto Jansen Ferreira5
Isabelle Cincinatus Dias dos Santos6
Abstract: Introduction: Child violence is a public health problem and is dened as any type of
action or omission that may harm physical or psychological integrity, freedom or the right to child
growth and development. In Brazil, as provided for in article 227 of the Federal Constitution and
article 13 of the Statute of the Child and Adolescent (ECA), abuse against children are the object
of mandatory notication, predicting penalties for professionals who fail to communicate the cases
of your knowledge. Since 2011, child violence, regardless of its type, has been part of the list of
compulsory notication in Law 4.730/2011, implying the doctor the duty to notify, as well as to
assume civil and criminal liability on the case . Objectives: To analyze the training of the students
1 Family and Community Medical, Master in Family Health and Professor at Estácio de Sá Uni-
versity (UNESA-DIDOMED)
2 Pediatrician, master in collective health and professor at Estácio de Sá University (UNESA-DI-
DOMED)
3 Academic of the 6th period of medicine at Estácio de Sá University (UNESA-DIDOMED)
4 Academic of the 12th period of the Medical Course at Estácio de Sá University (UNESA-DI-
DOMED)
5 Academic of the 6th period of the Medical Course at Estácio de Sá University (UNESA-DIDO-
MED)
6 Academic of the 12th period of the Medical Course at Estácio de Sá University (UNESA-DI-
DOMED)
186
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
of the fth and sixth year of the medical course regarding knowledge and conduct in the face of a
suggestive picture of violence against children and adolescents in the various scenarios of practical
action. METHODS: This is a quanti-quarter, transverse, exploratory characteristic descriptive
study. As a method of data collection, the application of questionnaires containing open and closed
questions, adapted from the questionnaire proposed by Dossi (2009), was used. The sending to
students of the 5th and 6th year of medicine occurred electronically. The ethical criteria dened
by Resolution No. 510 of the National Health Council (CNS), promulgated in 2016, were obeyed
on research involving human beings, being respected voluntary participation and anonymity of the
study population, using the free and informed consent form (Tcle). The research was submitted to
the Research Ethics Committee (CEP) and obtained its approval. 4. Results/Discussion: A total of
40 (forty) answers was obtained. Regarding the participants prole, it was observed that 70% of
participants are white ethnicity, 72.5% cisgender women and most aged 20 and 30 years old (77.5%).
Students dened childhood violence broadly, recognizing it as any kind of physical, psychological
and/or moral damage that can directly or indirectly compromise the physical or mental integrity
of children. Among the types of child violence mentioned are physical, psychological and sexual
aggression. A participant also stressed the importance of considering nutritional, vaccination and
educational neglect. One third of the inmates reported having had some kind of experience in their
clinical practices with situations suspected of child violence. Although most students (77%) consider
themselves able to identify and communicate situations of violence, 95% say they are unaware of
ows and protocols to follow. 5. CONCLUSIONS: Data reveals gaps in the preparation of students to
deal with child violence. One third of them did not have classes or discussions on the subject, while
32.5% received only one class and 35% had up to 3 classes on the subject. These ndings highlight
the need to improve the training of professionals in the eld, ensuring that they are prepared to deal
with such situations, as well as promote the well-being of children in dierent situations of violence.
Keywords: child abuse, general clinicians, medical education, knowledge.
187
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
INTRODUCTION
The occurrence of violence in the domestic environment is high and internationally recognized
as a major social and public health problem (Júnior et al., 2017). In relation to children, there is a crucial
aspect that is the power relationship of parents, main caregivers, before their children. This type of
violence is usually chronic, invisible and trivialized. However, it represents an important violation of
human rights, bringing pain and embarrassment to the victim, which can result in several complex and
often irreversible sequelae. The ancient concept of violence as biologically human by nature is no longer
accepted. Therefore, any act of violence is rational, intentional and represents a complex, dynamic,
biopsychosocial and multifactorial phenomenon (PARENT et al., 2022).
The realization of child violence, as previously exposed, as chronic, invisible and multifaceted
makes its management even more dicult, as well as the reversal of this sad reality. Some factors may
contribute to this invisibility, such as: the non -recognition of the child as a citizen, bearer of rights; the
understanding that abuse stems from the aggressor’s disease, motivating judicial decisions favorable
to the aggressor; and the victims blame, generating on the same eect of introspection, retraction,
embarrassment and psychic suering (Pfeier, 2022).
According to national legislation (Law 13431/2017), the following types of violence are dened:
a) physical violence: action that negatively impacts integrity or body health or causes physical suering;
b) Psychological violence: discrimination, threats, embarrassment, humiliation, manipulation, isolation,
curses, ridicule, indierence, among others, that harm their mental and emotional development. It is
also psychological violence to expose the child or adolescent directly or indirectly to violent crime
against someone in their family; c) Sexual violence: action that forces a child or adolescent to practice
or witness sexual act, in person or virtual manner. Sexual violence includes sexual abuse, commercial
sexual exploitation, and tracking in persons; d) Institutional Violence: Action practiced by a civil
servant who undermines care to the child or adolescent victim or witness to violence; e) retention or
destruction of personal documents, goods and resources, including those necessary for basic needs
188
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
(BRAZIL, 2017)
In Brazil, as provided for in Article 227 of the Federal Constitution and Article
13 of the Statute of the Child and Adolescent (ECA), abuse against children are the
object of mandatory notication, providing for professionals for professionals who fail to
communicate The cases of his knowledge, according to article 245 (Marin et al., 2015).
Since 2011, child violence, regardless of its type, has been part of the list of compulsory notication in
Law 4.730/2011, implying the doctor the duty to notify, as well as to assume civil and criminal liability
on the case (Júnior et al., 2017)
According to the United Nations International Emergency Fund, (UNICEF - United Nations
International Childrens Emergency Fund), in recent years, Brazil has had signicant advances in
ensuring the rights of children and adolescents, but social inequalities still aect many children and
adolescents in the country. Therefore, it is up to society to raise awareness of its share of responsibility
also in engaging in the ght against child violence through the identication and denunciation of possible
acts of violence and education of families in cultivating ethical values, loving bonds and compassion for
Next (Oliveira, 2021).
Child abuse brings sequelae such as social problems, diculty of same -sex relationships of
the abuser, psychiatric disorders, inadequate behaviors, use of substances, etc. Many victims children
self-coat, feel they contributed so that abuse could happen, and therefore do not always denounce the
abuser. Criminals, in most cases, are people close to the victim and mostly family members, leading to
a frequency in abuse, and generating a greater trauma in the child/adolescent (Florentino, 2015).
This study therefore proposes to analyze the training and knowledge of the future doctors who
are in the fth and sixth year of medical graduation in a higher education institution in the municipality
of Rio de Janeiro-RJ, regarding knowledge and conduct in the face of a suggestive picture of violence
against children and adolescents in the various scenarios of practical action. Thus, the objective of
the research is to analyze how the cases of violence against children and adolescents in the scenarios
experienced by the students are identied, considering how the knowledge of the ows and protocols
189
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
established by the Ministry of Health is built against these events.
METHODOLOGY
It is proposed a quanti-qualitative, transverse, exploratory characteristic descriptive study.
For the theoretical basis that guides the discussion and development of this work will be pursued
for indexed articles in the Scientic Electronic Library Online (Scielo), Pubmed and Latin American
and Caribbean Health Science Literature (Lilacs), published between 2015 and 2022 in Portuguese,
English and Spanish languages using the following descriptors: child abuse”, general clinicians”,
“medical education, “knowledge”. In addition to the Portuguese language, these descriptors will also
be researched in English and Spanish.
In order to achieve the objectives proposed for this research, it was opted for the use of a
questionnaire (preliminary version in Appendix I), which was adapted from the questionnaire proposed
by Dossi (2009), in the doctoral thesis presented to the Faculty of Araçatuba Dentistry of Paulista State
University (UNIFESP). The questionnaire, containing open and closed questions, was sent electronically
to students of the 5th and 6th grade of the Medicine Course (inmates) of a private university in the
municipality of Rio de Janeiro-RJ.
Included in the survey were the interns of the medical course at a private university of the
municipality of Rio de Janeiro-RJ who were in practical activities in the second half of 2023 and/or rst
half of 2024.
For the analysis of quantitative data, the Google Forms program was used, where the information
was compiled in spreadsheets to obtain tables and graphs. For analysis of qualitative data, we opted for
the method of content analysis, technique of research developed by Lawrence Bardin, who works with
the word, allowing to produce inference of the content of communication, categorizing words or phrases
that repeat themselves, inferring an expression that represent them (BARDIN, 2011).
In the development of the research were obeyed the ethical precepts contained in Resolution
190
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
No. 510, promulgated in 2016, of the National Health Council - Ministry of Health (MS), which includes
the guidelines and regulatory standards of research involving human beings, being respected voluntary
participation. and anonymity of the study population. A free and claried consent (TCL) consent and the
condentiality of the collected information was prepared. The research was submitted to the Research
Ethics Committee (CEP) of the educational institution where the research took place and obtained its
approval.
RESULTS
Forty academics participated in this research. It was noted that most, ie 72.5%, were cisgender
women, while 27.5% were cisgender men. Regarding ethnic composition, 70% of participants identied
themselves as whites, 20% as brown and 7.5% as yellow. Regarding the age group, most respondents,
corresponding to 77.5%, was in the range of 20 to 30 years. 15% were in the range between 30 and 34
years, while the remaining 7.5% were over 34 years old.
In the academic context, it is noteworthy that the sample has internal medical school. Most
respondents, 60%, were in the 11th period of the college, followed by 32.5% in the 9th period, 5% in the
10th period and 2.5% in the 12th period. It is noteworthy that 22.5% of participants had some previous
training in areas such as Physiotherapy, Dentistry, Pharmacy, Nutrition, Engineering, Administration
and Social Communication.
Research participants shared their perceptions of what constitutes violence against children,
and most highlighted any form of physical, moral or psychological damage that directly or indirectly
aects the well-being of the child. Although 62.5% claimed to be aware of what is considered child
violence, more than a third of future doctors (37.5%) did not feel safe to answer such a question.
Regarding signs and symptoms that raise suspicions of child violence during care, participants
highlighted: identication of bruises, marks, behavioral changes such as melancholy, silence accompanied
by embarrassment of parents, anxiety, aggressiveness, loss of appetite, low school performance and
191
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
retraction.
Regarding their experiences with cases of child violence, only a few students reported having
contact with suspected cases of child violence, and most of these cases involved sexual violence. In
addition, most participants (90%) could not describe how the procedures for care, notication and
monitoring of children in situations of violence are performed in the environments in which they work.
About the knowledge of the protocols developed by the Ministry of Health (MS) to address violence
against children and adolescents, the vast majority of interviewees (95%) admitted not to be familiar
with these protocols.
In view of the little experience reported in their stages and the sense of insecurity about
protocols and conduct, many students highlighted the need to develop more comprehensive theoretical
and practical classes during undergraduate, as only about 35% of participants reported having theoretical
classes About this approach, aiming to improve training to deal eectively with cases of child violence,
both in emergencies and primary health care (PHC).
DISCUSSION
Childrens violence is dened as any kind of action or omission that may harm physical or
psychological integrity, freedom or the right to child growth and development (SILVA et al., 2021),
being recognized as a public health problem , since its consequences aect not only individual but also
collective living conditions (JUNIOR et al., 2017). In this sense, any non -accidental damage against a
child, caused by their parents or caregivers, who threaten their biopsychosocial development, constitute
a scenario of child intrafamily violence (Koifman et al., 2012).
Aggression against children and adolescents can present itself in various forms, whether
physical, sexual, emotional or neglect. The infant’s exposure to any form of violence, especially in the
early stages of your life, can compromise your growth and physical and mental development, as well as
generate social, emotional, psychological, and catastrophic repercussions on adulthood behavior in the
192
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
behavior . Given this, it is possible to realize that the appeal is a public health problem, which can lead
to the development of serious physical health problems and characteristic psychological signs, such as
social isolation and learning diculties, and may even lead to death (Brazil , 2012; NUNES; SALES,
2016).
Childrens youth violence is pointed out as one of the main causes of childhood morbidity
and mortality, being present in deaths from external causes-accidents and violence-among the 15 main
causes of death of children under 5 years, especially in the subgroup of children from 1 to 4 years,
becoming a major health problem for families and society (Brazil, 2021).
Violence against children and adolescents is a serious worldwide problem, as on average 3,500
young people are death by mistreatment, whether physical or negligent. In addition, it is estimated that
the male child mortality coecient is 1.8 per 100,000 and female from 2.2 per 100,000 due to dierent
modalities of violence (MARIN et al., 2015).
According to a study by the Brazilian Public Security Forum, between 2019 and 2021, 129,844
occurrences of selected crimes against children and adolescents from 0 to 17 years in 12 units of the
national territory were identied. Among these, 56.6% are rape, 21.6% abuse, 18.1% willful body injury
in the context of domestic violence and 2.9% of intentional violent deaths. Most of these practices
occur within the domestic environment and the aggressors are usually the family circle and intimate
coexistence of the victims, showing that children and adolescents remain hostage to their aggressors
chronicly (Brazil, 2021).
The health professional should, therefore, know the various forms of manifestations of
violence, identify suspicious cases in the community, take care of children in situations of violence and
vulnerability, seek to expand the care and social protection network for decision making, Perform the
follow -up and monitoring of the child and family to continue care, as well as develop health promotion
actions and violence prevention (BRAZIL, 2012).
193
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
FINAL CONSIDERATIONS
Given the relevance of the theme, the formation of medical professionals able to deal with
situations of child violence is considered fundamental and urgent. The results of the research reveal that
most students recognize the existence of child violence, associating it with any form of physical, moral
or psychological damage to the child. However, the lack of direct experience with cases of child violence
was evident, which can generate insecurity of these future health professionals in the management of
these situations. Most participants revealed ignorance about service and notication procedures, as
well as the MS protocols. There was therefore a consensus on the need for broader training during
graduation, with emphasis on theoretical classes, practices, simulations and specic lectures, aiming to
prepare future doctors to eectively deal with these situations in dierent health contexts.
BIBLIOGRAPHIC REFERENCES
BARDIN, L. Content Analysis. São Paulo: Editions, 2011.
BRAZIL. Law No. 13, 431, of April 4, 2017. Establishes the system for guaranteeing the rights of the
child and adolescent victim or witness of violence.Brasília, DF: Ocial Gazette, 2017.
BRAZIL. Law 4,730, OF DECEMBER 28, 2011. Creates the Compulsory Notication of Violence
against Children or Adolescents and makes other arrangements. Brasília, DF: Ocial Gazette, 2011.
BRAZIL. Ministry of Health. Department of Health Care.Department of Primary Care. Child health
: growth and development / Ministry of Health. Department of Health Care. Department of Primary
Care. - Brasília: Ministry of Health, 2012. 272 p.: il. - (Basic Care Notebooks, nº 33.)
DOSSI, A. P. Violence against children: training, knowledge, perception and attitude of health and
education professionals. Doctoral Thesis presented to the Faculty of Dentistry of Araçatuba of the
Paulista State University (UNIFESP), 2009.
194
ISSN: 2763-5724 / Vol. 04 - n 04 - ano 2024
BRAZILIAN FORUM ON PUBLIC SECURITY. Brazilian Yearbook of Public Security - Special
Edition of 2022. Brazilian Forum of Public Safety, 2022. ISSN 1983-7364.
JUNIOR, G. B. S., Et al . IdenticAction and notication of maltreatment in children and adolescents
by family doctors in Ceará. Trab. Educ. Saúde, Rio de Janeiro, v. 15, n. 2, p. 469-484, May/Aug. 2017.
Available at: < https://www.scielo.br/j/tes/a/d7b7QZkbGDWGB8Gst3hvmhs/abstract/? Lang=pt
>.Accessed on 05 Apr 2023. KOIFMAN, L. ; MENEZES, R. M. ; BOHRER, K. A. Approach to
the theme “violence against Children” in the medical course of the Fluminense Federal University.
Brazilian Journal of Medical Education, v. 36, p. 172-179, 2012.
MARIN, F. S. Et al. THE ROLE OF THE HEALTH PROFESSIONAL IN THE FACE OF VIOLENCE
AND MISTREATMENT IN CHILDHOOD. Colloquium Vitae , vol. 7, n. Special, Jul–Dec, 2015,
p. 96-103. ISSN: 1984-6436. DOI: 10.5747/cv.2015.v07.nesp.000256. Accessed on: April 5, 2023.
NUNES, A. J., SALES, M. C. V. Violence against children in the Brazilian scenario. Science &
Collective Health, 21(3):871-880, 2016. DOI: 10.1590/1413-81232015213.08182014. Accessed on:
April 5, 2023. (nath)
OLIVEIRA, S. M. T. Epi proleDemological of violence against children and adolescents
in the Health Region of Jundiaí São Paulo before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. Thesis
(doctorate) - Postgraduate Program of the Faculty of Medicine of Jundiaí, Jundiaí, 2021. Available
at: < https://primeirainfancia.jundiai.sp.gov.br/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/VERSA_O-FINAL-
DOUTORADO-REVISADA-PO_S-DEFESA-7-de-jan-2022.pdf >. Accessed on Apr 24, 2023.
PARENTE, E. A. Et al . Pediatric TreatyA: Brazilian Society of Peditry. /Organizers Luciana
Rodrigues Silva ... [et al.]. 5. ed. V. 1 and 2. Barueri: Editora Mente Aberta, 2022.
Protection of Children and Adolescents against Violence. UNICEF. Available at: < Https://www.
Unicef.org/brazil/protection-of-children-and-adolescents-against-violence >. Accessed on Apr 24,
2023.
SILVA, A. L. B. S. Et al . Approach From Violence Children’s In the Strategy Health From
Family : Factors Interveners E Strategies Of Coping . Magazine Baiana Of Nursing , V
. 35, 2021.