Keywords
legal norm, private law, public law, bodies of state power, social relations.
How to Cite
V. Teremtsova, N. ., O. Dubov, G. ., & V. Kotenko, M. . (2020). MАІN DIFFERENTIATION CRITERIA BETWEEN PRIVATE AND PUBLIC LAW. Revista Gênero E Interdisciplinaridade, 1(01). https://doi.org/10.51249/gei.v1i01.76
Abstract
The object of research is division of law. This study is focused on the fact that, in addition to branches in the structure of law, legal norms can be divided into two large groups: private and public law. The division of the system of to public and private is the most researched and widely recognized in jurisprudence. The purpose of the article to provide criteria for public and law private law division. The division of the right to public and private is universally recognized, however criteria for the division remain controversial. Goal of this study is to prove that the main criteria for the division of the law to private and public depends on the relationships and interest of the subjects of the law and their legal relationship. According to this, private law is governed by the rules and principles of the legal relationship between individuals and legal entities that satisfy an individual interest. In the course of research, the author proposed the definition of public and private law and updated the criteria for their division. In the course of the research it was recognized that there are different approaches to the division of the right to private and public.
References
Agarkov MM. (1992). The value of private law. Jurisprudence, 1, 31–39.
Allalyev RM. (2019). Religious origins of the rule of law conception in the United States. Amazonia Investiga, 7(14), 212-217.
Belov VA. (2008). Civil law: Theory and practice trends/under general. Moscow: Yurait-Izdat, 559 p.
Belov VYe. (2012). On the Question of Private Relations. Education and Law, 12, 64–73.
Bolgova VV. (2008a). Mixed Theories of the differentiation of the law to the public and the private. Economic and Legal Issues, 1, 29–37.
Bolgova VV. (2008b). The general characteristic of the material theories of differentiation of public and private law. Law and Politics, 7, 156–164.
Borisova LV. (2013). On the grounds (criteria) of dividing the law to private and public. Bulletin MGOU, 1, 13–14.
Cherepakhin BB. (2001). Works on civil law. http://civil.consultant.ru.
Eriashvili ND. (2012). Legislation as the basis of the unity of private and public interests. Education and Law, 12, 99–108.
Erofeyeva DV, Shagieva RV. (2012). Public and private law: Some questions of history and theory. Education and Law, 12, 109–116.
Gordadze G, Kerimov V, Giruts M, Poshibaeva A, Koshelev V. (2018). Genesis of the asphaltite of the Ivanovskoe field in the Orenburg region, Russia. Fuel, 216, 835-842.
Grudtsyna LYu, Ivanova SA. (2012). Private and public law: an introduction to the problem. Modern Law, 4, 3–7.
Grudtsyna LYu. (2012). Private and public in law. Bulletin of Financial University, 1, 44–59.
Grudtsyna LYu. (2013). Problems of the theory of law. Education and Law, 1, 31–42.
Guliyev IS, Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Bondarev AV. (2018). The estimation of the generation potential of the low permeable shale strata of the maikop caucasian series. Socar Proceedings, 1, 4-20.
Holder Ch, Khurana V, Harrison F, Jacobs L. (2016). Robotics and law: key legal and regulatory implications of the robotics age. Computer Law and Security Review, 32, 383–402.
Jhering R. (1875). The spirit of Roman law at the various stages of its development. Saint Petersburg: Printing House V. Bezobrav and Company, 309 p.
Kerimov V, Rachinsky M, Mustaev R, Serikova U. (2018a). Geothermal conditions of hydrocarbon formation in the South Caspian basin. Iranian Journal of Earth Sciences, 10(1), 78-89.
Kerimov VYu, Gorbunov AA, Lavrenova EA, Osipov AV. (2015). Models of hydrocarbon systems in the Russian Platform-Ural junction zone. Lithology and Mineral Resources, 50(5), 394-406.
Kerimov VYu, Gordadze GN, Lapidus AL, Giruts MV, Mustaev RN, Movsumzade EM, Zhagfarov FG, Zakharchenko MV. (2018b). Physicochemical properties and genesis of the asphaltites of Orenburg oblast. Solid Fuel Chemistry, 52(2), 128-137.
Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Bondarev AV. (2016). Evaluation of the organic carbon content in the low-permeability shale formations (as in the case of the Khadum suite in the Ciscaucasia region). Oriental Journal of Chemistry, 32(6), 3235-3241.
Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Osipov AV. (2018c). Peculiarities of hydrocarbon generation at great depths in the crust. Doklady Earth Sciences 483(1), 1413-1417.
Kerimov VYu, Rachinsky MZ. (2016). Geofluid dynamic concept of hydrocarbon accumulation in natural reservoirs. Doklady Earth Sciences, 471(1), 1123-1125.
Kerimov, VY, Leonov, MG, Osipov, AV, Mustaev, RN, Khai, V. (2019). Hydrocarbons in the basement of the South China Sea (Vietnam) shelf and structural-tectonic model of their formation. Geotektonika, 53(1), 42-59.
Kosarenko NN. (2007). Category “interest” in the system of public and private law. Knowledge. Understanding. Skill, 3, 153–162.
Kozhevnikov SN. (2005). Public and private law. Substantive and procedural law. International Public and Private Law, 2, 2–3.
Kuznetsov NB, Kerimov VYu, Osipov AV, Bondarev AV, Monakova AS. (2018). Geodynamics of the Ural foredeep and geomechanical modeling of the origin of hydrocarbon accumulations. Geotectonics, 52(3), 297-311.
Lapidus AL, Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Movsumzade EM, Salikhova IM, Zhagfarov FG. (2018a). Natural bitumens: physicochemical properties and production technologies. Solid Fuel Chemistry, 52(6), 344-355.
Lapidus AL, Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Movsumzade EM, Zakharchenko MV. (2018b). Caucasus Maykopian Kerogenous shale sequences: generative potential. Oil Shale, 35(2), 113-127.
Lapidus AL, Kerimov VYu, Tret'yakov VF, Talyshinskii RM, Ilolov AM, Movsumzade EM. (2018c). Extraction of asphaltite with toluene. Solid Fuel Chemistry, 52(4), 256-259.
Law of Ukraine “On the Public Prosecutor’s Office”. (2014). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Marchenko MN. (2012). Theory of state and law. Moscow: Prospect, 656 p.
Matuzov NI, Malko AV. (2004). Theory of state and law. Moscow: Yurist, 320 p.
Muromtsev SA. (2004). Definition and basic division of law. Saint Petersburg: Publishing House of the Law Faculty of St. Petersburg State University, 169 p.
Portnova I, Portnova T. (2019). The importance of academic education in contemporary architectural and sculptural practice. Journal of Mathematics and Computer Science, 1, 518–526.
Portnova TV. (2018). Synthesized nature of fine arts and ballet theater: System analysis of genre development. European Journal of Science and Theology, 14(5), 189–200.
Portnova TV. (2019). Composite – image organization of the dramaturgy of dance based paintings. Amazonia Investiga, 8(20), 415–421.
Resolution of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on the accession of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic to the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. (1990). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
The Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine (2004). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
The Constitution of Ukraine. (1996). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Tyshchenko OV, Vyshnovetska SV, Vyshnovetskyi VM. (2018). Subsistence minimum as a financial economic indicator of the human development of the population of Ukraine. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 27, 533–541.
Universal Declaration on Human Rights by Ukraine. (2013). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Verdict of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. (1997). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Vyshnovetska SV, Timysh IS, Tyshchenko OV. (2018). The dynamics of personal request for the labor market of Ukraine: Financial and Economic Trends. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 25, 269–277.
Zaiarnyi O. (2018). Directions for improving the legal liability of medical organizations for artificial intelligence systems application. Medicine and Law, 37(2), 363–382.
Zekker F. (2010). To the question of the distinction between private and public law. Business, Management and Law, 1, 90–99.
Zharikov RV, Bezpalov VV, Lochan SA, Barashkin MV, Zharikov AR. (2018). Economic security of regions as a criterion for formation and development of agricultural clusters by means of innovative technologies. Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development, 18(4), 431-439
Allalyev RM. (2019). Religious origins of the rule of law conception in the United States. Amazonia Investiga, 7(14), 212-217.
Belov VA. (2008). Civil law: Theory and practice trends/under general. Moscow: Yurait-Izdat, 559 p.
Belov VYe. (2012). On the Question of Private Relations. Education and Law, 12, 64–73.
Bolgova VV. (2008a). Mixed Theories of the differentiation of the law to the public and the private. Economic and Legal Issues, 1, 29–37.
Bolgova VV. (2008b). The general characteristic of the material theories of differentiation of public and private law. Law and Politics, 7, 156–164.
Borisova LV. (2013). On the grounds (criteria) of dividing the law to private and public. Bulletin MGOU, 1, 13–14.
Cherepakhin BB. (2001). Works on civil law. http://civil.consultant.ru.
Eriashvili ND. (2012). Legislation as the basis of the unity of private and public interests. Education and Law, 12, 99–108.
Erofeyeva DV, Shagieva RV. (2012). Public and private law: Some questions of history and theory. Education and Law, 12, 109–116.
Gordadze G, Kerimov V, Giruts M, Poshibaeva A, Koshelev V. (2018). Genesis of the asphaltite of the Ivanovskoe field in the Orenburg region, Russia. Fuel, 216, 835-842.
Grudtsyna LYu, Ivanova SA. (2012). Private and public law: an introduction to the problem. Modern Law, 4, 3–7.
Grudtsyna LYu. (2012). Private and public in law. Bulletin of Financial University, 1, 44–59.
Grudtsyna LYu. (2013). Problems of the theory of law. Education and Law, 1, 31–42.
Guliyev IS, Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Bondarev AV. (2018). The estimation of the generation potential of the low permeable shale strata of the maikop caucasian series. Socar Proceedings, 1, 4-20.
Holder Ch, Khurana V, Harrison F, Jacobs L. (2016). Robotics and law: key legal and regulatory implications of the robotics age. Computer Law and Security Review, 32, 383–402.
Jhering R. (1875). The spirit of Roman law at the various stages of its development. Saint Petersburg: Printing House V. Bezobrav and Company, 309 p.
Kerimov V, Rachinsky M, Mustaev R, Serikova U. (2018a). Geothermal conditions of hydrocarbon formation in the South Caspian basin. Iranian Journal of Earth Sciences, 10(1), 78-89.
Kerimov VYu, Gorbunov AA, Lavrenova EA, Osipov AV. (2015). Models of hydrocarbon systems in the Russian Platform-Ural junction zone. Lithology and Mineral Resources, 50(5), 394-406.
Kerimov VYu, Gordadze GN, Lapidus AL, Giruts MV, Mustaev RN, Movsumzade EM, Zhagfarov FG, Zakharchenko MV. (2018b). Physicochemical properties and genesis of the asphaltites of Orenburg oblast. Solid Fuel Chemistry, 52(2), 128-137.
Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Bondarev AV. (2016). Evaluation of the organic carbon content in the low-permeability shale formations (as in the case of the Khadum suite in the Ciscaucasia region). Oriental Journal of Chemistry, 32(6), 3235-3241.
Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Osipov AV. (2018c). Peculiarities of hydrocarbon generation at great depths in the crust. Doklady Earth Sciences 483(1), 1413-1417.
Kerimov VYu, Rachinsky MZ. (2016). Geofluid dynamic concept of hydrocarbon accumulation in natural reservoirs. Doklady Earth Sciences, 471(1), 1123-1125.
Kerimov, VY, Leonov, MG, Osipov, AV, Mustaev, RN, Khai, V. (2019). Hydrocarbons in the basement of the South China Sea (Vietnam) shelf and structural-tectonic model of their formation. Geotektonika, 53(1), 42-59.
Kosarenko NN. (2007). Category “interest” in the system of public and private law. Knowledge. Understanding. Skill, 3, 153–162.
Kozhevnikov SN. (2005). Public and private law. Substantive and procedural law. International Public and Private Law, 2, 2–3.
Kuznetsov NB, Kerimov VYu, Osipov AV, Bondarev AV, Monakova AS. (2018). Geodynamics of the Ural foredeep and geomechanical modeling of the origin of hydrocarbon accumulations. Geotectonics, 52(3), 297-311.
Lapidus AL, Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Movsumzade EM, Salikhova IM, Zhagfarov FG. (2018a). Natural bitumens: physicochemical properties and production technologies. Solid Fuel Chemistry, 52(6), 344-355.
Lapidus AL, Kerimov VYu, Mustaev RN, Movsumzade EM, Zakharchenko MV. (2018b). Caucasus Maykopian Kerogenous shale sequences: generative potential. Oil Shale, 35(2), 113-127.
Lapidus AL, Kerimov VYu, Tret'yakov VF, Talyshinskii RM, Ilolov AM, Movsumzade EM. (2018c). Extraction of asphaltite with toluene. Solid Fuel Chemistry, 52(4), 256-259.
Law of Ukraine “On the Public Prosecutor’s Office”. (2014). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Marchenko MN. (2012). Theory of state and law. Moscow: Prospect, 656 p.
Matuzov NI, Malko AV. (2004). Theory of state and law. Moscow: Yurist, 320 p.
Muromtsev SA. (2004). Definition and basic division of law. Saint Petersburg: Publishing House of the Law Faculty of St. Petersburg State University, 169 p.
Portnova I, Portnova T. (2019). The importance of academic education in contemporary architectural and sculptural practice. Journal of Mathematics and Computer Science, 1, 518–526.
Portnova TV. (2018). Synthesized nature of fine arts and ballet theater: System analysis of genre development. European Journal of Science and Theology, 14(5), 189–200.
Portnova TV. (2019). Composite – image organization of the dramaturgy of dance based paintings. Amazonia Investiga, 8(20), 415–421.
Resolution of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR on the accession of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic to the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. (1990). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
The Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine (2004). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
The Constitution of Ukraine. (1996). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Tyshchenko OV, Vyshnovetska SV, Vyshnovetskyi VM. (2018). Subsistence minimum as a financial economic indicator of the human development of the population of Ukraine. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 27, 533–541.
Universal Declaration on Human Rights by Ukraine. (2013). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Verdict of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. (1997). https://zakon.rada.gov.ua.
Vyshnovetska SV, Timysh IS, Tyshchenko OV. (2018). The dynamics of personal request for the labor market of Ukraine: Financial and Economic Trends. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 25, 269–277.
Zaiarnyi O. (2018). Directions for improving the legal liability of medical organizations for artificial intelligence systems application. Medicine and Law, 37(2), 363–382.
Zekker F. (2010). To the question of the distinction between private and public law. Business, Management and Law, 1, 90–99.
Zharikov RV, Bezpalov VV, Lochan SA, Barashkin MV, Zharikov AR. (2018). Economic security of regions as a criterion for formation and development of agricultural clusters by means of innovative technologies. Scientific Papers Series Management, Economic Engineering in Agriculture and Rural Development, 18(4), 431-439
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
Metrics
Metrics Loading ...